Left-behind communities unable to challenge poor care

More than 37 million people in England and Wales live in a local authority area without a single community care legal aid service, including over 7.5 million people aged 65 and over, the Law Society said as it published analysis revealing catastrophic legal aid deserts for community care across the country.

A new interactive map shows the vanishing number of providers in each local authority area.* 79% of local authorities now have no publicly funded legal advice for vulnerable people to challenge local authority community care arrangements.

The situation is even worse than the map suggests because many of these community care legal aid lawyers provide advice in a subset of cases known as Court of Protection work, in which the client may be deprived of their liberty because they can no longer make decisions for themselves.

“A cared-for person fighting to get vital welfare services or remain in their own home will tell you legal aid is a lifeline,” Law Society president Simon Davis said.

“But almost two thirds of us live in a local authority area without a single community care legal aid service, so all too often the most vulnerable people – who may be elderly, housebound, disabled – cannot get the expert legal advice they desperately need when their care arrangements fall short.

“Anyone trying to resolve a care issue is likely to need face-to-face professional advice urgently and be unable to travel long distances to get that tailored advice.” Catastrophically low rates of pay for exceptionally complex, sophisticated work are forcing legal professionals across the country to withdraw from legal aid as the work is simply not economically viable.

The fees government pays for civil legal aid provision have not increased since 1994, equating to a 49% real-terms reduction. On top of this fees were cut by a further 10% in 2011.

“Inadequate community care could leave a disabled person without the support they need to dress or prepare food; an elderly person might not be able to access their community or challenge the closure of a care home,” Simon Davis said.

“The combined knock-on of shrinking local authority budgets and an advice sector decimated by legal aid cuts mean the demand for advice in community care law far outstrips supply.

“Our members tell us all too often they are having to make the heart-breaking decision to turn away people because they simply do not have the capacity to take cases on.

“Fewer and fewer solicitors are choosing to go into this area of work that requires in-depth knowledge of the welfare sector, sophisticated understanding of the law and highly developed interpersonal skills.

“If the government does not wake up to the impending catastrophe I fear this specialism could disappear altogether, leaving society greatly diminished and disempowered.

“The government must make urgent changes so everyone who has a right to state-funded legal advice can get the advice they need when they so desperately need it. Legal rights are meaningless if people cannot enforce them.”

Notes to editors

*Preview the interactive map showing providers by local authority area  

** Percentage of the population living in a local authority with no community care legal aid provider, by region
Region % of population (living in a local authority with no community care legal aid provider)
East Midlands 80.30
East of England 89.85
London 21.53
North East 59.67
North West 58.95
South East 80.93
South West 71.89
Wales 72.40
West Midlands 69.86
Yorkshire and The Humber 59.31
England and Wales Total 64.80

The heat map was compiled from the Directory of legal aid providers which is published by the Legal Aid Agency on the GOV.UK website.

The Directory provides information regarding the number and geographical location of firms holding legal aid contracts in England and Wales and is regularly updated.

The heat map data is from September 2019. Contract changes since then (to date three further providers have withdrawn) are not shown on the map, but are reflected in the table above and data in the release above)

Spending on early legal advice to help resolve community care issues has halved in the last ten years.

  • This is not in any way offset by government spending on court (civil) representation because of stronger legal protection for people deprived of their liberty in care homes and elsewhere.
  • Early advice about community care can nip problems in the bud before they escalate, can make sure that people have the help they need at the time they need it, and avoid great distress to those affected.

Even if there is one community care legal aid provider in a large area, this gives rise to a range of problems:

  • Anyone on an income low enough to qualify for legal aid, let alone if they need local authority care, is unlikely to be able to afford to travel a great distance to see a solicitor.
  • Most people challenging a local authority over the care they are getting (or not getting) are likely have serious logistical challenges if they must travel across a county to find a provider, particularly in rural areas with patchy public transport.
  • If they are disabled or mentally incapacitated travelling will be even more difficult for them.
  • One firm is unlikely to have capacity to provide advice to all those who need it across a large area, particularly as many firms have just one solicitor doing community care work.

About the Law Society

The Law Society is the independent professional body that works globally to support and represent solicitors, promoting the highest professional standards, the public interest and the rule of law.

Press office contact: Harriet Beaumont | harriet.beaumont@lawsociety.org.uk | 0208 049 3854 (out of hours: 020 3189 1880)

Maximise your Law Society membership with My LS