You are here:
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blog
  4. Workers' rights without enforcement are meaningless

Workers' rights without enforcement are meaningless

10 February 2017
by 

With cases of exploitation thrusting UK employment law into the spotlight, Nick Denys looks at how the system can be made fairer for all.

 Reading time: 2 minutes


Growing concerns around the ‘gig economy’, zero-hour contracts and other non-standard working arrangements have placed UK employment law under scrutiny in recent years. Research from Citizens Advice suggests that one in 10 people are bogusly defined as self-employed, meaning they lose out on holiday and sick pay, plus the right to be paid the national minimum wage. It also means loses of £314 million a year for the exchequer and puts responsible businesses at a competitive disadvantage to those willing to bend or break the rules.

In a move to combat exploitation, the government recently launched a £1.7 million advertising campaign to encourage workers to check they are being paid at least the minimum wage. A lack of awareness and clarity around workers’ rights is certainly an issue, but there's a greater problem at the heart of UK employment law: when faced with what can seem a daunting, complex and time-consuming legal route to justice, many workers simply don’t feel able to improve their situation.

In our employment legislative framework the obligation lies with the individual to challenge mistreatment. If an employee feels confident enough to do so, they must enter into a legal process with an uncertain outcome and run the risk of employer reprisals, including being blacklisted. It’s hardly surprising that so few under payment and unpaid wages actions have been brought.

Mauled in the press and slammed by MPs, Sports Direct’s reprehensible treatment of employees became well known. Yet the retailer’s working practices were uncovered during an Competition Commission investigation into the retailer’s part acquisition of competitor. It was this examination of a commercial transaction that brought the wrongdoing to light, rather than the actions of an exploited employee.

A review of adult social care by the National Audit Office found that up to 220,000 care workers in England were paid less than the minimum wage. HMRC found that 50 per cent of care sector providers were paid less than legal minimum. Despite this evidence, only six care providers have been identified and back pay provided to just 202 workers.

In the Law Society’s evidence to the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee inquiry into the future of work and the rights of workers, we urged it to consider placing the onus on bosses to prove compliance with employment standards. Shifting this relatively small responsibility to employers could be an important step in ensuring protection for workers and creating a fairer system for everyone.

Tags: business | modern slavery | employment law

About the author

Nick Denys is the policy adviser who leads on employment and family law matters at the Law Society.

  • Share this page:
Authors

Adam Johnson | Adele Edwin-Lamerton | Ahmed Aydeed | Alex Barr | Alex Heshmaty | Alexa Lemzy | Alexandra Cardenas | Amanda Adeola | Amanda Carpenter | Amanda Jardine Viner | Amy Bell | Amy Heading | an anonymous sole practitioner | Andrew Kidd | Andy Harris | Anna Drozd | Annaliese Fiehn | Anne Morris | Anne Waldron | anonymous female solicitor | Asif Afridi and Roseanne Russell | Bansi Desai | Barbara Whitehorne | Barry Wilkinson | Becky Baker | Ben Hollom | Bhavisha Mistry | Bob Nightingale | Bridget Garrood | Caroline Marlow | Caroline Roddis | Caroline Sorbier | Carolyn Pepper | Catherine Dixon | Chris Claxton-Shirley | Christina Blacklaws | Ciaran Fenton | CV Library | Daniel Matchett | Daphne Perry | David Gilroy | David Yeoward | Douglas McPherson | Duncan Wood | Elijah Granet | Emily Miller | Emily Powell | Emma Maule | Floyd Porter | Gary Richards | Gary Rycroft | Graham Murphy | Gustavo Bussmann | Hayley Stewart | Hilda-Georgina Kwafo-Akoto | Ignasi Guardans | James Castro Edwards | Jane Cassell | Jayne Willetts | Jeremy Miles | Jerry Garvey | Jessie Barwick | Joe Egan | Jonathan Andrews | Jonathan Fisher | Jonathan Smithers | Jonathon Bray | Julian Hall | Julie Ashdown | Julie Nicholds | Justin Rourke | Karen Jackson | Kate Adam | Katherine Cousins | Kaweh Beheshtizadeh | Kayleigh Leonie | Keiley Ann Broadhead | Kerrie Fuller | Kevin Hood | Kevin Poulter | Larry Cattle | Laura Bee | Laura Devine | Laura Uberoi | Leah Glover and Julie Ashdown | Leanne Yendell | LHS Solicitors | Lucy Parker | Maria Shahid | Marjorie Creek | Mark Carver | Mark Leiser | Markus Coleman | Martin Barnes | Matt Oliver | Matthew Still | Max Rossiter | Melissa Hardee | Neil Ford | Nick Denys | Nick O'Neill | Nick Podd | Nikki Alderson | Oz Alashe | Patrick Wolfe | Paul Rogerson | Pearl Moses | Penny Owston | Peter Wright | Philippa Southwell | Preetha Gopalan | Prof Sylvie Delacroix | Rachel Brushfield | Rafie Faruq | Ranjit Uppal | Ravi Naik | Remy Mohamed | Richard Collier | Richard Coulthard | Richard Heinrich | Richard Messingham | Richard Miller | Richard Roberts | Rob Cope | Robert Bourns | Robin Charrot | Rosa Coleman | Rosy Rourke | Saida Bello | Sally Azarmi | Sally Woolston | Sam De Silva | Sara Chandler | Sarah Austin | Sarah Crowe | Sarah Henchoz | Sarah Smith | Shereen Semnani | Shirin Marker | Sofia Olhede | Sonia Aman | Sophia Adams Bhatti | Sophie O'Neill-Hanson | Steve Deutsch | Steve Thompson | Stuart Poole-Robb | Susan Kench | Suzanne Gallagher | The Law Society Digital and Brand team | Tom Ellen | Tony Roe Solicitors | Tracey Calvert | Umar Kankiya | Vanessa Friend | Vicki Butler | Vidisha Joshi | William Li | William McSweeney