After 16 years of practice, I refused to take a brief for the very first time.
A last-minute case was returned to me from another set of chambers when I was seven months pregnant with my third child. It was a serious and complex prosecution sexual abuse re-trial with multiple child complainants. Papers more than two feet deep, the pink brief ribbon barely holding them together due to their sheer weight and volume, were couriered to my home address late after close of business.
The brief contained no indictment, no opening note, no case summary and there were several complainant DVDs to view. My other children were 2 years and 17 months old respectively at the time. My husband worked away. I had to be ready for a clean start the next morning in a non-local court. I said "No".
How many times this month have you undertaken a task at work because you didn't want to rock the boat? As a former criminal barrister with 19 years' experience, I've seen countless examples of lawyers saying yes to things to prove a point, not let others down, or fearing others' judgment:
- The pupil barrister or trainee solicitor "first in, last out", feeling that their tenancy or training contract relies upon their constant availability and visibility
- The solicitor seeking promotion having more and more burdensome tasks demanded of them by the senior partner
- The associate solicitor taking out of hours calls from the CEO, originally to facilitate global conference calls, but becoming the regular expectation
- The criminal barrister taking on a last-minute return, far beneath their level of seniority or, as in my original example, the "bag of rats" that seriously test usual standards of preparedness and professionalism.
The fear of saying no
How easy do they, or you, find saying no?
I'm now a specialist corporate and executive coach and have delivered several coaching workshops on this topic, I see many of us struggle with asserting ourselves around saying no. We take on far too much, spread ourselves too thinly and, as a consequence, end up doing lots of things badly rather than a few things well.
To what are you prepared to say yes?
I prefer to ask, to what am I prepared to say yes?
At the Criminal Bar, return briefs are common-place. Inevitably a degree of flexibility is required. As a pupil or associate solicitor, you can expect a certain amount of "putting yourself out" to achieve tenancy or promotion. It may be politic to crack on with certain things for a short period. But over time, this will dilute our values and beliefs, making this approach unsustainable.
Confidence, communication and personal choice
If we look back at times in our professional lives when we've said yes to something to prove a point, being honest, wasn't this truly due to a lack of personal confidence? An inability to effectively prioritise our own objectives over the expectations of the organisation within which we work? Doesn't "learning to say no" really come down to improving our own ability to confidently assert ourselves through clear and effective communication?
I'm not suggesting don't be a team player. I'm advocating a move away from the misconception that saying no means we're not capable. My experiences demonstrate the opposite. A senior colleague, fuming at having been asked by the clerks to take a case far beneath her level of experience and call, ultimately refused. To have taken it on, she explained, would have affected her credibility and standing.
Only when I, like her, became clear about my own values and self-worth, and examined what was most important, did I first recognise the power to say no was within me. The confidence to assert this power was as refreshing as it was liberating. That was when I said no. No to the task. Yes to personal choice. And yes to a much more manageable and enjoyable work life.
My tips around saying no
- Be clear and confident about your values and belief
- Ask "Whose plan am I working to?"
- Be prepared to more readily communicate what it is you ARE prepared to do
- Learn the art of saying no through practice, practice, practice!
A great book recommendation on this challenging work-place topic is Geoff McKeown's Essentialism. He gives eight simple and effective examples of saying "no" without using the actual word.
Views expressed in our blogs are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Law Society.
Learn how a company can say sorry when something goes wrong, without worrying that it amounts to an admission of guilt from our risk and compliance head Pearl Moses in her blog: Owning up to mistakes - what is the right thing to do?
Read registered psychologist Caroline Marlow's blog on: Is employee resilience training needed in the workplace?
Members can call our free confidential helplines staffed by solicitors for advice, anti-money laundering, conveyancing, private client, litigation, solicitors' costs and professional indemnity insurance support. Staffed Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm
How are you, really? LawCare promotes and supports good mental health and wellbeing in the legal community. Call 0800 279 6888 Monday to Friday 9am to 7.30pm, weekends and bank holidays 10am to 4pm